His CPA Said the IRS Would AbTake The Retirement Account

IRS Hardship Status

A retired client came to me with $245,000 in his IRA and $55,000 owed to the IRS, but the reality is the Social Security he receives isn't enough to cover his monthly bills.

I presented the financials and made a case for why he should be placed in currently not collectible status. He was not protecting that IRA for some distant future. He was already pulling from it every month to cover rent, groceries, and everything Social Security couldn’t.

Didn't matter.

The representative told me flat out that she wouldn’t agree to it with that much sitting in his retirement account.

I see this situation consistently in my practice. A client has a tax debt, a retirement account that looks big on paper, and a trusted professional who has done the reasonable math and concluded the account is going to the IRS.

Here are the five things I want every CPA, financial advisor, and attorney with a client in this position to know.

1. Why Everyone Assumes the Account Has to Go

When a taxpayer asks the IRS for anything based on ability to pay, he fills out a financial statement, Form 433-A. He lists his retirement accounts right alongside his bank accounts, vehicles, and home.

For an Offer in Compromise, the IRS requires that the offer include equity in those accounts. So when a CPA sees $245,000 in an IRA next to a $55,000 balance, the conclusion feels obvious.

The client has the money, so the IRS will want it.

That’s a reasonable prediction, and most competent professionals would make it. The problem is that very few of them have ever seen that assumption tested against the IRS, and acting on it without testing it costs far more than most people realize.

2. What Cashing Out Actually Costs

A withdrawal from a traditional IRA is taxable income. To end up with $55,000 to send to the IRS, my client would have had to withdraw even more because a meaningful piece of the withdrawal goes to taxes first.

For retirees, there’s a second cost. A large withdrawal can push more of a client’s Social Security into taxable income, so the same distribution raises his tax bill a second way.

My client was over 59½, so he avoided the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty, but many of your clients won’t, and for them the cost climbs again.

He still would have paid well over $55,000 to clear a $55,000 debt, using money he was living on and had no way to rebuild at his age. And he would have done it to pay a debt the IRS might never have collected.

3. How Currently Not Collectible Actually Works

Most professionals have heard of Currently Not Collectible. Far fewer think it applies to a client with a six-figure retirement account.

If a client’s income, after the expenses the IRS allows for basic living, leaves nothing to pay the debt, the IRS can classify the account as not collectible for now.

Collection stops, which means no levies on his bank account and no garnishments of his income. The IRS will typically file a lien and review his finances from time to time, but the pressure stops.

Meanwhile, the collection statute keeps running. The IRS generally has ten years from assessment to collect a tax debt, and when that window closes, the remaining balance goes away.

In my practice, Currently Not Collectible and Partial Pay Installment Agreements, combined with the statute of limitations, have produced more outcomes where clients pay less than they owe than the Offer in Compromise has.

For this client, the oldest year on the account had 6 years left before the statute of limitations. If nothing changes, that year drops off in six years, and his IRA never has to pay for it.

So the question was never whether hardship status existed. The question was whether the IRS would grant hardship status to a man with $245,000 in his IRA.

4. What the IRS Actually Did

The first answer was no.

The representative looked at the financial statement, saw the IRA, and told me she wouldn’t approve hardship status with that much in his retirement account.

That’s the moment where most cases end.

The professional on the phone relays the IRS’s answer to the client, and the client starts filling out the withdrawal paperwork.

Instead, I escalated the case to a manager.

I made a hard pitch because I knew I was right. I went into a deep financial analysis showing that the client’s Social Security didn’t cover his basic living expenses, and that the IRA was the money he was living on and that it had to last him the rest of his life.

The manager said he’d think about it.

Three days later, the manager called back and approved Currently Not Collectible status, and my client kept his IRA.

That outcome wasn’t luck. The IRS has been reluctant to take retirement accounts from taxpayers who qualify for hardship, especially older taxpayers who depend on that money to live.

The Internal Revenue Manual (IRM 5.11.6.2) directs the IRS to consider whether a taxpayer depends on retirement funds for necessary living expenses before it goes after them.

A frontline representative doesn’t always apply that consideration on the first call, which is why the first answer on a retirement account often isn’t the final one.

If the manager had refused, the next step would have been a written request with a full memo explaining why the account shouldn’t be ruled out as a hardship. Filing a Request for Appeal would be next.

Most professionals never get past the first answer.

TL;DR

⏩ A large retirement account does not automatically rule out IRS hardship status.

⏩ Cashing out triggers income tax, can make more Social Security taxable, and may add a 10 percent penalty under 59½.

⏩ Currently Not Collectible stops collection while the collection statute keeps running.

⏩ My client had $245,000 in his IRA and owed $55,000. The first representative refused hardship, and a manager approved it three days later.

⏩ The IRS’s first answer on a retirement account often isn’t its final one.

PS, retirement accounts aren’t the only place where a client’s first move can cost them. If a client’s business has fallen behind on payroll taxes, I wrote a two-page guide on what to do in the first 48 hours.

It’s written for the business owner, so you can send it to them directly, but it’s worth a read yourself, because it covers the early decisions that determine whether the debt becomes the owner’s personal problem: https://stephen-a-weisberg-tax-attorney.kit.com/payroll

- Stephen A Weisberg

➥ Contact Attorney Stephen A. Weisberg for a free Tax Debt Analysis.

Contact Me Here: https://www.weisberg.tax/contact-1

Email: s.weisberg@weisberg.tax

Phone/Text: (248) 971-0885

Address: 300 Galleria Officentre, Suite 402, Southfield, MI 48034

Next
Next

Strategies for Resolving Client Issues With The New IRS Collections